Still Unfolding

On freedom, disappointment and living well

A gull with outstretched wings in grey ink wash against a muted pale-blue sky.

What does it mean to be free?

Most of us first answer by pointing outward. We think of the freedom to choose, a chance given, no one saying no. That kind of freedom matters. A resident who is never handed the instruments cannot learn to operate, however ready she is. A young pianist who is never invited to perform cannot discover what she can do before an audience. Opportunities are real, and being passed over has real consequences.

But there is more to it, and it took me much longer to notice. Even when no one is blocking my way, I may be carrying something inside me that narrows where I can go: other people’s expectations, perhaps, or my need to be recognized, or a fixed picture of who I must be.

What I keep returning to is how I can give myself wholeheartedly to something I love and still be free when my abilities, my opportunities or my place in it change. Looking back over my years in surgery, I can see that I have lived this in three different ways, each a different kind of freedom, or a different way of lacking it.

At first, I lived through other people’s eyes.

As a junior resident, I prepared carefully for every case. I read the night before, rehearsed each step in my head and practised in the wet lab using donated eye-bank eyes, until the movements felt familiar. Then I went to the operating room and, often, spent the whole day just watching. Some attendings gave me little opportunity to operate. I could prepare diligently and still be given no chance to show what I had learned, like a musician never given the solo, or a player who never leaves the bench. I could not say so, either. A resident who complains about being passed over risks being seen as difficult. When I did get a turn, I found that living tissue behaves nothing like the eye-bank eyes I had practised on. Nervousness added to the strangeness, and my hands were sometimes less steady than they had been in the lab. I worried that a few unsteady minutes would be all the attending remembered of me.

The operating room was only part of it. Residency also meant being on call late into the night, studying on weekends, and seeing friends outside of medicine enjoy free time I did not have, wondering what I was missing. Nearly every part of that life seemed to be measured by someone: attendings, the quiet comparisons among fellow residents, and, most relentlessly, myself. I expected to excel at all of it at once. When I fell short in one area, I felt it said something about the whole of me.

What stayed with me was not the technical difficulty. It was the disappointment of feeling that others did not see me as capable, and how quickly that feeling began to seem like the truth. My sense of who I was rose and fell with each decision. A good morning in the operating room made me feel like a surgeon; a bad one made me feel like an impostor, or a failure. Without noticing, I had given the people who decided authority not only over my opportunities but over my understanding of myself.

Later, I found freedom inside the work.

It came gradually. I could not point to a single day. Skill grew the way balance comes on a bicycle. Someone holds the seat and runs beside you. You wobble, pedal, wobble a little less. At some point you are riding on your own, and only later do you discover that the hand let go some time ago. No one could have scheduled that moment, including me. Preparation mattered, and so did encouragement and the chances I was eventually given. But my skill emerged in its own time. The days I spent just watching had not decided what kind of surgeon I would become.

As I gained experience, I came to know a freedom I had not imagined as a junior resident. In a careful case there are long stretches of what many people now call flow, when preparation disappears into action, and my hands respond to the tissue before I have time to think. Everything else falls away, and the whole world becomes the field under the microscope. That absorption is one of the deepest satisfactions I know, and it is genuinely free. Musicians know it in the middle of a phrase, athletes in the middle of play.

It took me longer, however, to see its limit. I could be free at the operating table and not entirely free away from it. Being a surgeon had become so much of who I was that I scarcely noticed how much my sense of myself still depended on doing it, and on the recognition that came with it.

Only slowly did I glimpse a freedom wider than the work.

Teaching opened the way. As an attending, I began giving residents part of a case, one step and then another, entrusting more as their ability grew. From that side I could see things a resident could not: whether the day’s surgeries were running behind, how complicated a particular child’s eye was, how much more experienced a pair of hands had become since last month. I also came to realize how much I missed. I watched one performance on one day. I did not see the hours of preparation, or what a resident could do on a different day, or what she would be able to do a year later. I suspect the same is true of anyone who must choose, whether a teacher, a conductor or a coach.

Some of the residents I once guided now operate as my colleagues, and a few have taught me things I did not know. Each stage of those relationships has asked something different of me: first to hold on, then to let go, then to learn to stand alongside. I think of the attendings who passed me over, too. Some of them were probably right about that particular day. None of them could see the years ahead. Neither, at the time, could I.

This wider freedom does not come from caring less. I care about surgery as much as I ever have. It is the freedom to care deeply and feel disappointment fully, and then to ask what is called for now. Sometimes the answer is to persevere: to keep preparing, keep showing up, and wait for the next chance. Sometimes it is to adapt: to notice that something has changed, in my abilities or my circumstances, and to respond differently. Telling the two apart is not always easy, and I do not always get it right. What I love can stay whole even when my place in it shifts, and my life remains larger than any one of its parts. I can ask, without feeling devastated, who I would be if the identity I cherish were called into question.

Years later, I found a similar journey described in a classic of Chinese philosophy written more than two thousand years ago. The thinker Zhuangzi writes of people whose sense of themselves rests on suiting one office or pleasing one ruler. He then turns to a man who would not be spurred on if the whole world praised him, nor dismayed if the whole world condemned him, yet who, Zhuangzi says, had still not fully established himself. Higher still is one who could ride the wind and travel lightly, yet who still depended on something: the wind. And he points beyond them all, to someone who moves with the changes themselves and depends on nothing in particular.

I saw something of my own path in that ladder. I knew the lowest rung well from my years as a young resident. I have known, too, the lightness of riding the wind, and how easily the wind can fall away. The rest I am still learning.

Our lives unfold according to our capacities, our circumstances and our relationships. We cannot force that unfolding, but we can respond to it flexibly, and that is where our freedom lies.

If freedom lies in how we respond as life changes, then a good life cannot depend on always rising. The usual word for such a life is flourishing, the common translation of Aristotle’s eudaimonia, and I have never been entirely comfortable with it. Flourishing suggests growth: more ability, more achievement, more recognition. It fits the years when everything is increasing. It fits less well a surgeon whose hands are no longer as steady, a singer whose voice has changed, or anyone growing older and losing abilities they once took for granted. I have come to prefer a plainer phrase, one Aristotle himself used: living well. Living well does not belong only to the years of rising. What matters most to me is that I can still ask what it means to live well as life begins to draw in.

I sometimes wonder what I would say to my younger self, the resident in the wet lab, if I could. I am not sure she would have listened, and I am not sure she needed to. Much of what I know now I could only learn by living through it. Perhaps it would be enough to tell her that the morning she was passed over was real, and so was the disappointment, and neither was the whole story. The story was still unfolding. It still is.

Next essay: Room to Move →

← All essays

← Home